Search found 19 matches

by FabianH
23 Jan 2022, 17:10
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM
Replies: 9
Views: 1869

Re: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM

Another result: I have now tried all possible combinations. Simulated testcase is a surface PM machine without magnetization (magnets behave like iron). If I include the rotor air between the magnets in the respective calculations (Torque Group, Component), the results are almost identical. That als...
by FabianH
23 Jan 2022, 15:46
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM
Replies: 9
Views: 1869

Re: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM

I think that I found my mistake. I assumed that Mesh Rotate 3 works with the increment of the rotation and doesn't need the absolute angle. Some examples are with tx and others define the line with tx(0) - tx(1). Body Force 1 Mesh Rotate 3 = Variable Time Real MATC "tx" End instead of Body...
by FabianH
20 Jan 2022, 02:53
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Some tips for 2D electrical machine computation
Replies: 7
Views: 1522

Re: Some tips for 2D electrical machine computation

Hi, after using many open source and commercial electromagnetic solvers, my opinion is that the best programs have the best documentation or simple GUI. Regardless of the performance. From my point of view, you can see that from the fact that many refer to femm, which is good entry-level software. E...
by FabianH
20 Jan 2022, 02:16
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM
Replies: 9
Views: 1869

Re: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM

Hello Martin, maybe the example is not so simple after all. Even with small increments there is a small offset, which means that the error is not that big in the end. It still bothers me because I can't explain it. The small error margin of your lossless machine is impressive. Especially because I c...
by FabianH
19 Jan 2022, 03:23
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM
Replies: 9
Views: 1869

Re: Best Practice to Calculate Torque for PMSM

I can confirm, that there is no big difference between Arkkio and the nodal force method. My observation is more, that i have a shift in the mean of the torque which differ from zero, when i reduce the step size of the mesh rotation. A denser mesh doesn't bring any improvement. I know that the torqu...
by FabianH
06 Jan 2022, 02:20
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Unite Mesh - Wrong Order of Bodies
Replies: 7
Views: 878

Re: Unite Mesh - Wrong Order of Bodies

Thanks for your work! I tested also some variants (with gmsh). Some comments on your approach: The mesh with the larger number of bodies should be used first for -unite so that the second mesh will completely renumbered to save the order The approach with the Physical Surface just work for the first...
by FabianH
05 Jan 2022, 23:36
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Unite Mesh - Wrong Order of Bodies
Replies: 7
Views: 878

Re: Unite Mesh - Wrong Order of Bodies

After some try and error I had the same idea, but it produce unfortunately an incomprehensible result when I try this ElmerGrid 2 2 mesh_pm_rotor -in mesh_pm_stator -2d -unite -autoclean -out mesh_pm Results in ! ----- names for bodies ----- $ RotorIron = 1 $ RotorAir = 2 $ RotorAirgap = 3 $ Magnet1...
by FabianH
05 Jan 2022, 17:20
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Unite Mesh - Wrong Order of Bodies
Replies: 7
Views: 878

Unite Mesh - Wrong Order of Bodies

Hello Everyone, I have two mesh files, which I want to unite with ElmerGrid: .\gmsh model_stator_pmsm_type1_out.geo -2 -o mesh_pm_stator.msh ElmerGrid 14 2 mesh_pm_stator.msh -2d -autoclean .\gmsh model_rotor_pmsm_type1_out.geo -2 -o mesh_pm_rotor.msh ElmerGrid 14 2 mesh_pm_rotor.msh -2d -autoclean ...
by FabianH
28 Jun 2021, 02:14
Forum: ElmerSolver
Topic: Set Active Solvers
Replies: 3
Views: 1057

Set Active Solvers

Dear All, the following definition can be found in several test cases: Equation 1 Active Solvers(2) = 2 3 End Solver 1 is the Procedure = "RigidMeshMapper" "RigidMeshMapper" for rotation, Solver 2 and 3 for solving the relevant equation and Solver 4 is Procedure = "SaveData&...